73 Nfl Would You Rather Questions

Hey football fans! Ever found yourself in a lively debate about the NFL, wondering what crazy scenarios you'd rather face than miss a game-winning field goal? That's where Nfl Would You Rather Questions come in! They're a fun way to get people talking, arguing, and laughing about their favorite sport by presenting tough choices.

What Are Nfl Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They a Touchdown?

So, what exactly are Nfl Would You Rather Questions? They're basically little puzzles that ask you to pick between two often-difficult or hilarious football-related situations. Think of it like this: "Would you rather have to punt every offensive play, or would you rather have to throw an interception every time your opponent scores?" They force you to really think about what you value most as a fan or even what you'd be willing to endure for the love of the game.

These kinds of questions have become super popular because they're incredibly engaging. They're not just for die-hard fans; anyone who's ever watched a game can jump in. They're perfect for:

Breaking the ice at parties
Starting friendly debates with friends
Filling awkward silences during commercial breaks
Testing how much someone *really* loves their team

The real magic of Nfl Would You Rather Questions lies in their ability to create memorable moments and spark interesting conversations. The importance of these questions is that they tap into our shared passion for the NFL and allow us to express our fandom in a playful, often competitive, way. They can lead to:

Unexpected alliances ("You'd really pick *that* over *this*? We can't be friends!")
Hilarious arguments about player strengths and weaknesses
A deeper understanding of what makes fans tick

Quarterback Quandaries

Would you rather have a quarterback who throws for 500 yards but 5 interceptions every game, or a quarterback who throws for 200 yards and 0 interceptions every game?
Would you rather have a quarterback who can only throw left-handed, or a quarterback who can only throw underhand?
Would you rather have a quarterback who fumbles every time he gets sacked, or a quarterback who gets sacked on every single play?
Would you rather have a quarterback who celebrates every first down with a touchdown dance, or a quarterback who celebrates every incompletion with a cartwheel?
Would you rather have a quarterback who throws a perfect spiral 90% of the time but trips every time he throws a pass, or a quarterback who throws wobblers 50% of the time but is incredibly agile?
Would you rather have a quarterback who wears a cape to every game, or a quarterback who insists on wearing roller skates under his pads?
Would you rather have a quarterback who can only throw to his own team's linemen, or a quarterback who can only throw to the opposing team's defensive backs?
Would you rather have a quarterback who talks to the football before every snap, or a quarterback who yodels after every touchdown?
Would you rather have a quarterback who always throws passes that are slightly too high, or a quarterback who always throws passes that are slightly too low?
Would you rather have a quarterback who has to wear a giant inflatable sumo suit for the entire game, or a quarterback who has to play with a bright pink nose cone?
Would you rather have a quarterback who cries after every incomplete pass, or a quarterback who laughs after every interception?
Would you rather have a quarterback who runs out of the huddle backwards, or a quarterback who has to bark like a dog on every play?
Would you rather have a quarterback who only throws the ball after his shoelaces are perfectly tied, or a quarterback who only throws the ball after he eats a full sandwich?
Would you rather have a quarterback who calls his own plays but always calls for a run up the middle, or a quarterback who has the coach call plays but always calls for a flea-flicker?
Would you rather have a quarterback who throws touchdowns only on fourth down, or a quarterback who throws interceptions only on first down?
Would you rather have a quarterback who has to wear oven mitts on both hands, or a quarterback who has to play with pool noodles for sleeves?
Would you rather have a quarterback who insists on wearing a helmet with a propeller on top, or a quarterback who insists on wearing a tutu under his uniform?
Would you rather have a quarterback who can only throw while spinning, or a quarterback who can only throw while hopping on one foot?
Would you rather have a quarterback who throws a pass that always hits the referee in the helmet, or a quarterback who throws a pass that always lands perfectly on the opposing team's kicker's head?
Would you rather have a quarterback who talks to the referees constantly with elaborate excuses for every call, or a quarterback who only communicates by miming?

Defensive Dilemmas

Would you rather have a defense that forces 5 turnovers a game but gives up 400 passing yards, or a defense that gives up 100 total yards but never forces a turnover?
Would you rather have a defensive player who can only tackle by sliding, or a defensive player who can only tackle by doing a flying leap?
Would you rather have a defense that always blitzes but never sacks the quarterback, or a defense that never blitzes but always gets a sack?
Would you rather have a defensive lineman who only celebrates sacks by doing the chicken dance, or a defensive lineman who only celebrates sacks by playing an air guitar solo?
Would you rather have a defensive back who intercepts the ball every time it's thrown his way but also gets flagged for pass interference on every other play, or a defensive back who never gets a penalty but also never breaks up a pass?
Would you rather have a linebacker who can only chase the ball carrier while singing opera, or a linebacker who can only chase the ball carrier while doing the Macarena?
Would you rather have a defense that is amazing against the run but terrible against the pass, or terrible against the run but amazing against the pass?
Would you rather have a defensive player who screams "Boo!" every time he makes a tackle, or a defensive player who whispers "You're next" after every tackle?
Would you rather have a defense that always plays prevent coverage on third downs, or a defense that always plays man-to-man on every single play?
Would you rather have a defensive player who has to wear oven mitts to make tackles, or a defensive player who has to play with a giant inflatable hammer?
Would you rather have a defensive player who can only tackle after doing a somersault, or a defensive player who can only tackle after shouting a Shakespearean insult?
Would you rather have a defense that always gives up a touchdown in the final two minutes of every half, or a defense that always gives up a field goal as time expires?
Would you rather have a defensive coach who calls plays using only interpretive dance, or a defensive coach who calls plays using only animal sounds?
Would you rather have a defensive player who can only sack the quarterback from behind the line of scrimmage, or a defensive player who can only sack the quarterback by doing a karate chop?
Would you rather have a defense that always allows the opposing team to score on their first drive, or a defense that always allows the opposing team to score on their last drive?
Would you rather have a defensive player who has to wear a chicken costume during games, or a defensive player who has to wear a giant clown wig?
Would you rather have a defensive player who can only celebrate a tackle by doing a backflip, or a defensive player who can only celebrate a tackle by singing the national anthem?
Would you rather have a defense that always gives up long plays but never allows short gains, or a defense that always allows short gains but never gives up long plays?
Would you rather have a defensive player who can only tackle by tackling himself, or a defensive player who can only tackle by tackling the referee?
Would you rather have a defense that always gets penalized for holding, or a defense that always gets penalized for offsides?

Special Teams Shenanigans

Would you rather have a kicker who can only kick with his eyes closed, or a punter who can only punt with his non-dominant foot?
Would you rather have a punter who always kicks the ball so low it hits the offensive line, or a punter who always kicks the ball so high it goes out of bounds?
Would you rather have a kickoff returner who always fair catches the ball, or a kickoff returner who always tries to run it out of the end zone but fumbles?
Would you rather have a kicker who only makes field goals from midfield or beyond, or a kicker who only makes extra points?
Would you rather have a punter who shouts "Fore!" after every punt, or a punter who plays a short fanfare after every punt?
Would you rather have a punt returner who runs backwards for the first 10 yards, or a punt returner who trips over his own feet every time he catches the ball?
Would you rather have a kicker who wears roller skates on the field, or a kicker who has to wear a helmet made of Jell-O?
Would you rather have a punter who can only punt while juggling, or a punter who can only punt while wearing a full knight's armor?
Would you rather have a kickoff specialist who always kicks the ball out of bounds, or a kickoff specialist who always kicks it short and directly to the other team's best returner?
Would you rather have a field goal unit that always snaps the ball perfectly but the hold is always bad, or a field goal unit that always has a perfect hold but the snap is always bad?
Would you rather have a punt returner who can only catch the ball with his teeth, or a punt returner who can only return the ball by doing a handstand?
Would you rather have a kicker who only kicks the ball with his head, or a kicker who only kicks the ball with his feet but has to wear clown shoes?
Would you rather have a punter who always punts the ball directly into the stadium scoreboard, or a punter who always punts the ball straight up into the air?
Would you rather have a kickoff returner who always runs in the wrong direction, or a kickoff returner who always fumbles on the first tackle?
Would you rather have a kicker who celebrates every made field goal by doing a backflip, or a kicker who celebrates every made field goal by singing a lullaby?
Would you rather have a punter who can only punt while standing on one leg, or a punter who can only punt while wearing a blindfold?
Would you rather have a field goal unit where the holder is always a quarterback who thinks he's a wide receiver, or a field goal unit where the kicker is always an offensive lineman who thinks he's a punter?
Would you rather have a punt returner who can only catch the ball while doing the worm, or a punt returner who can only return the ball by walking backwards?
Would you rather have a kicker who can only kick accurately if he's wearing a full clown outfit, or a kicker who can only kick accurately if he's blindfolded and spinning?
Would you rather have a punter who always punts the ball backwards into his own end zone, or a punter who always punts the ball straight into the stands?

Coaching Conundrums

Would you rather have a coach who is a genius strategist but has a terrible temper, or a coach who is incredibly calm but makes questionable play calls?
Would you rather have a coach who is always yelling at the referees, or a coach who is always talking to the players in a baby voice?
Would you rather have a coach who insists on wearing a different outlandish costume every game, or a coach who communicates solely through interpretive dance on the sideline?
Would you rather have a coach who can only call plays by drawing them on a whiteboard for all to see, or a coach who can only call plays by singing them in opera?
Would you rather have a coach who meticulously studies every opponent but gets terrible game-day decisions wrong, or a coach who has no preparation but somehow pulls off brilliant last-minute adjustments?
Would you rather have a coach who only allows players to speak in rhymes, or a coach who only allows players to speak in riddles?
Would you rather have a coach who insists on wearing a giant foam finger to every press conference, or a coach who always wears sunglasses indoors?
Would you rather have a coach who believes in advanced analytics for everything, or a coach who relies purely on gut feeling and superstition?
Would you rather have a coach who yells at players for being too successful, or a coach who praises players for every minor mistake?
Would you rather have a coach who wears a full mascot costume on the sidelines, or a coach who has a pet parrot that squawks the plays?
Would you rather have a coach who only uses hand gestures to call plays, or a coach who only uses pre-recorded sound effects?
Would you rather have a coach who insists on eating a whole raw onion before every game, or a coach who drinks pickle juice through a straw during halftime?
Would you rather have a coach who celebrates every touchdown by doing a somersault, or a coach who celebrates every turnover by doing a victory lap around the stadium?
Would you rather have a coach who is always trying to trade away your best players, or a coach who is always trying to draft players who are also professional dog walkers?
Would you rather have a coach who believes the game is played with giant marshmallows, or a coach who believes the game is played with actual bowling balls?
Would you rather have a coach who wears a powdered wig to every game, or a coach who wears roller skates under his suit?
Would you rather have a coach who can only draw plays in ketchup, or a coach who can only draw plays with his nose?
Would you rather have a coach who celebrates every interception with a confetti cannon, or a coach who celebrates every completion with a synchronized swimming routine?
Would you rather have a coach who communicates with players via carrier pigeon, or a coach who communicates with players through charades?
Would you rather have a coach who believes that the football is actually a pet rock, or a coach who believes that the goalposts are actually giant slides?

Fan Frustrations

Would you rather have to wear your team's jersey inside out for every game, or have to paint your face with your team's colors every game?
Would you rather have to sing your team's fight song after every defensive stop, or have to do a victory dance after every successful offensive play?
Would you rather have to eat a hot dog every time your team scores a touchdown, or have to drink a soda every time your team gets a first down?
Would you rather have to cheer for the opposing team's kicker every time he attempts a field goal, or have to boo your own team's quarterback after every incompletion?
Would you rather have to wear a giant inflatable helmet to every game, or have to carry a noisemaker that constantly plays a kazoo solo?
Would you rather have to attend every game dressed as your team's mascot, or have to sit in the nosebleed section for every game?
Would you rather have to yell "Touchdown!" at the top of your lungs every time your team gets past midfield, or have to do a little jig every time your team gets a penalty?
Would you rather have to watch every game on mute, or have to watch every game with the volume turned all the way up to maximum?
Would you rather have to wear mismatched socks for the entire season, or have to wear your team's helmet everywhere you go?
Would you rather have to bring a giant inflatable football to every tailgate, or have to bring a confetti cannon to every tailgate?
Would you rather have to cheer for the opposing team's coach after every good play they make, or have to clap for the opposing team's cheerleaders after every touchdown?
Would you rather have to wear a t-shirt that says "I Love the Referees" to every game, or have to wear a t-shirt that says "My Favorite Player is the Water Boy"?
Would you rather have to sing a solo at halftime of every game, or have to perform a puppet show at halftime of every game?
Would you rather have to wear a sign that says "I Root for the Coin Toss" to every game, or have to wear a sign that says "My Team is Fine"?
Would you rather have to eat a bowl of lukewarm gravy every time your team commits a turnover, or have to drink a glass of pickle juice every time your team gets a penalty?
Would you rather have to wear a giant foam finger on your head for the entire game, or have to wear a pair of googly eyes on your nose?
Would you rather have to yell "Interception!" every time the opposing team completes a pass, or have to yell "Sack!" every time your own team is tackled?
Would you rather have to wear a superhero cape to every game, or have to wear a knight's helmet to every game?
Would you rather have to cheer for the opposing team's special teams, or have to cheer for the opposing team's quarterback?
Would you rather have to eat a whole lemon every time your team is on offense, or have to drink a glass of vinegar every time your team is on defense?

Player Power Plays

Would you rather be a star player on a losing team, or a benchwarmer on a championship team?
Would you rather have incredible talent but no work ethic, or average talent but an unmatched work ethic?
Would you rather be known as the dirtiest player in the league, or the most penalized player in the league?
Would you rather have a career-ending injury in your prime, or play out your entire career with nagging injuries that limit your performance?
Would you rather be able to break any tackle but never be able to throw a pass, or be able to throw a perfect pass but never be able to run?
Would you rather have your face plastered on every billboard in the city but never win a Super Bowl, or win multiple Super Bowls but be completely unknown?
Would you rather be able to talk to animals but only about football, or be able to fly but only when you're wearing cleats?
Would you rather have the body of a defensive lineman but the speed of a quarterback, or the speed of a wide receiver but the strength of a tight end?
Would you rather have the ability to teleport but only to the opposing team's bench, or have the ability to control the weather but only during fourth downs?
Would you rather have the ability to read minds but only when they're thinking about football, or have the ability to talk to ghosts but only if they were former NFL players?
Would you rather have an insatiable appetite for victory but also an insatiable appetite for pizza, or have a moderate desire for victory and a strict diet?
Would you rather have the power to make any penalty disappear but only once per game, or the power to force a turnover but only by sacrificing your favorite jersey?
Would you rather have the ability to slow down time but only for offensive plays, or have the ability to speed up time but only for defensive plays?
Would you rather have the ability to communicate with inanimate objects but only football equipment, or have the ability to change the color of any object but only to your team's colors?
Would you rather have the ability to perfectly predict the outcome of every game but be unable to bet on them, or have the ability to bet on every game but never be able to predict them?
Would you rather have the power to make yourself invisible but only on the field, or have the power to make anyone else invisible but only on the sidelines?
Would you rather have the ability to speak every language but only when you're wearing a helmet, or have the ability to play any instrument but only when you're wearing shoulder pads?
Would you rather have the ability to predict the next play but be unable to tell anyone, or have the ability to tell anyone but be unable to predict the next play?
Would you rather have the power to make yourself incredibly strong but only when you're tired, or incredibly fast but only when you're slow?
Would you rather have the ability to control your dreams but only if they involve football, or have the ability to control your nightmares but only if they involve losing to your rival?

So, there you have it! A whole bunch of Nfl Would You Rather Questions to get your football discussions rolling. Whether you're a seasoned fan or just getting into the game, these scenarios are sure to spark some fun and maybe even a little friendly competition. Keep debating, keep laughing, and most importantly, keep enjoying the greatest sport on Earth!