73 Moral Would You Rather Questions

Ever found yourself in a conversation where someone asks, "Would you rather do X or Y?" Sometimes these are just for fun, but other times, they make you really stop and think about what's most important to you. That's where Moral Would You Rather Questions come in! They're not just about silly choices; they’re about exploring our values and figuring out what we'd do when faced with tough decisions that involve right and wrong.

What Are Moral Would You Rather Questions and Why Do We Love Them?

Moral Would You Rather Questions are like mini thought experiments designed to get you thinking about ethics and values. They present two difficult or tricky options, and you have to pick one. The cool thing is, there's usually no easy "right" answer. You have to weigh the pros and cons of each choice, and often, both options have a downside. This makes them super engaging because they force us to confront our own beliefs and what we consider to be the lesser of two evils.

People love these questions for a bunch of reasons:

They're a fun way to learn about yourself and others.
They can spark interesting debates and conversations.
They help us understand different perspectives on what's right and wrong.
They are important for developing critical thinking skills and understanding the complexities of moral decision-making.

Moral Would You Rather Questions are used in all sorts of ways. You might see them:

As icebreakers at parties or meetings.
In classroom discussions to teach about ethics.
On social media to get people talking.
As a tool for personal reflection to understand your own moral compass.

Self-Sacrifice vs. Protecting Loved Ones

Would you rather sacrifice your own life to save five strangers, or sacrifice five strangers to save your own life?
Would you rather have your best friend go through immense pain for a week, or have you experience mild, constant discomfort for a year?
Would you rather accidentally reveal a secret that deeply hurts your family, or deliberately lie to your family about something important?
Would you rather be able to erase one of your own painful memories, or erase one of your parent's painful memories?
Would you rather lose all your memories of your childhood, or lose all your memories of your adult life?
Would you rather save one person you love from a terrible accident, or save ten people you don't know from a minor inconvenience?
Would you rather have your pet suffer for an hour to save a human child, or have the human child suffer for an hour to save your pet?
Would you rather be universally disliked but safe, or be loved by everyone but constantly in danger?
Would you rather have your child cheat on a test to get into a good school, or have them fail and miss out on opportunities?
Would you rather always say exactly what you think, no matter how hurtful, or always lie to protect people's feelings?
Would you rather accidentally cause a small injury to someone you care about, or intentionally cause a minor annoyance to a stranger?
Would you rather have your child experience bullying without fighting back, or have them fight back aggressively and face consequences?
Would you rather be the one to betray a friend for personal gain, or be the friend who is betrayed?
Would you rather have your entire family know a deeply embarrassing secret about you, or have one stranger know it?
Would you rather give up your favorite hobby forever to help someone in desperate need, or refuse and let them suffer?
Would you rather have your sibling constantly ask you for money they never pay back, or have them constantly ask for your advice and ignore it?
Would you rather be responsible for a mistake that costs your company a lot of money but saves a life, or be responsible for a mistake that costs your company a little money but harms no one?
Would you rather save a rare animal that is vital to an ecosystem, or save a rare plant that is vital to an ecosystem?
Would you rather always feel guilty about something you didn't do, or never feel guilty about something you did do?
Would you rather have your child be the bully or the bullied?

Honesty vs. Kindness

Would you rather tell a brutal truth that devastates a friend, or tell a kind lie that makes them happy?
Would you rather accidentally overhear a secret that could ruin someone's life if revealed, or be asked to keep a secret that is hurting someone?
Would you rather have your partner always know when you're lying, or have you always know when they're lying?
Would you rather be forced to reveal an embarrassing secret about yourself to your entire school, or be forced to reveal an embarrassing secret about a friend?
Would you rather always have to be perfectly honest, even if it's painful, or always have to be polite, even if it means being dishonest?
Would you rather have your boss lie to you to keep you motivated, or tell you the harsh truth and risk you quitting?
Would you rather be able to lie flawlessly without anyone ever knowing, or be unable to lie at all?
Would you rather accidentally hurt someone's feelings with the truth, or intentionally deceive someone for their perceived benefit?
Would you rather have your child learn to lie effectively for protection, or learn to face the truth no matter the cost?
Would you rather confess a small, insignificant lie you told years ago, or let it remain hidden forever?
Would you rather receive brutally honest criticism that helps you improve, or gentle, encouraging feedback that doesn't?
Would you rather have a friend who always tells you what you want to hear, or a friend who always tells you the truth, even if it's hard?
Would you rather be forced to be rude to a stranger every day, or be forced to be overly polite to someone you dislike?
Would you rather your child always tell the truth even if it means getting into trouble, or lie to avoid trouble?
Would you rather have your spouse keep a secret from you that benefits them greatly, or tell you the secret and cause them great hardship?
Would you rather always have to give brutally honest advice, or never be able to give advice?
Would you rather be known as someone who is brutally honest but hurtful, or someone who is kind but sometimes misleading?
Would you rather your child be honest with you about their mistakes even if they face punishment, or lie to avoid punishment?
Would you rather have the ability to know if someone is lying to you, or the ability to lie so well that no one can detect it?
Would you rather always be kind and never tell the truth, or always tell the truth and never be kind?

Personal Gain vs. Universal Good

Would you rather have a million dollars and a lifetime of bad luck, or be poor but have a lifetime of incredible good fortune?
Would you rather discover a cure for cancer but keep it a secret for your own gain, or share it freely with the world and remain in obscurity?
Would you rather live in a world where everyone is equally happy, or a world where you are infinitely happier than everyone else?
Would you rather invent a technology that makes your life incredibly easy but has a small chance of harming others, or invent a technology that helps everyone but brings you no personal benefit?
Would you rather be the richest person in a dying world, or the poorest person in a thriving world?
Would you rather have the power to control your own destiny completely, or the power to control the destiny of one other person?
Would you rather have a life of extreme luxury but no real accomplishments, or a life of struggle but significant positive impact on the world?
Would you rather have the ability to read minds for personal gain, or the ability to make anyone happy with a touch?
Would you rather gain immense personal power but lose all your friends, or keep your friends but remain powerless?
Would you rather be a universally loved but powerless leader, or a feared but highly effective dictator?
Would you rather have the secret to eternal youth for yourself, or the secret to making everyone else immortal?
Would you rather have the power to erase all your own mistakes, or the power to erase all of humanity's mistakes?
Would you rather be incredibly successful but unhappy, or moderately successful and deeply happy?
Would you rather have the ability to predict the future for personal gain, or the ability to prevent any disaster you foresee?
Would you rather live a life of comfort and safety with no major impact, or a life of risk and hardship that benefits millions?
Would you rather have the power to grant yourself any material possession, or the power to grant any person one wish?
Would you rather be a hero who sacrifices everything for the greater good, or a villain who achieves great personal power?
Would you rather have your wildest dreams come true but only for yourself, or have everyone else's wildest dreams come true but not yours?
Would you rather be the one who benefits from a system that harms many, or be harmed by a system that benefits many?
Would you rather have infinite knowledge for yourself, or the ability to solve all the world's problems?

Inconvenience vs. Minor Harm

Would you rather be constantly slightly hungry, or constantly slightly thirsty?
Would you rather have a persistent, annoying itch you can never quite scratch, or a persistent, minor headache?
Would you rather every light you use flicker constantly, or every door you open squeak loudly?
Would you rather have to walk everywhere you go, or only be able to travel by slow-moving donkey?
Would you rather wear shoes that are always slightly too small, or clothes that are always slightly too big?
Would you rather always have a small pebble in your shoe, or always have a bit of sand in your eye?
Would you rather have your phone battery die exactly when you need it most, or have your internet connection always be incredibly slow?
Would you rather have to answer every question with a riddle, or have to ask every question as a statement?
Would you rather have to eat every meal with your non-dominant hand, or have to sleep sitting up?
Would you rather have a constant, faint smell of rotten eggs around you, or a constant, faint sound of a buzzing fly?
Would you rather have to listen to the same annoying song on repeat for an hour every day, or have to watch a very boring documentary for an hour every day?
Would you rather have your keys always be just out of reach, or your wallet always be just out of sight?
Would you rather always have to whisper everything you say, or always have to shout everything you say?
Would you rather have a mild rash that never goes away, or a recurring minor stubbed toe?
Would you rather have every piece of technology you use glitch occasionally, or have every written word you read be slightly misspelled?
Would you rather have to do a small, embarrassing dance every time you enter a room, or have to sing a short, silly song every time you leave a room?
Would you rather have your alarm clock go off five minutes earlier than you set it every day, or have it go off five minutes later?
Would you rather have to drink all your beverages lukewarm, or have to eat all your food cold?
Would you rather always feel like you're about to sneeze, or always feel like you're about to cough?
Would you rather have your internet cut out for five minutes every hour, or have your television randomly switch channels?

Extreme Scenarios

Would you rather be stranded on a deserted island with a pack of wolves, or stranded in the middle of the ocean with no land in sight?
Would you rather have to fight a horse-sized duck, or one hundred duck-sized horses?
Would you rather be able to talk to animals but they all hate you, or be unable to talk to animals but they all love you?
Would you rather have to eat a live spider every day, or drink a cup of your own blood every day?
Would you rather be trapped in a room with a ticking time bomb that you can't disarm, or trapped in a room with a venomous snake that is constantly moving?
Would you rather have the ability to teleport anywhere, but you always arrive naked and disoriented, or the ability to fly, but only at walking speed?
Would you rather live in a world without music, or a world without books?
Would you rather have to wear a clown suit every day for the rest of your life, or have to sing everything you say?
Would you rather be able to breathe underwater but not on land, or breathe on land but only in very short bursts underwater?
Would you rather have super strength but no control over it, or super speed but you can only run in circles?
Would you rather have to fight a single, extremely large shark, or a swarm of medium-sized jellyfish?
Would you rather have the power to control minds, but only to make people do silly things, or the power to control the weather, but only to make it slightly overcast?
Would you rather be hunted by an invisible monster, or hunted by a monster that makes loud, scary noises?
Would you rather have to eat only one food for the rest of your life, or have to drink only one beverage for the rest of your life?
Would you rather be able to communicate with aliens but they are hostile, or be able to communicate with ghosts but they are annoying?
Would you rather have to walk through a field of razor blades, or swim through a pool of acid?
Would you rather be able to control fire, but it always burns you too, or control water, but it always makes you incredibly cold?
Would you rather live in a world where it always rains, or a world where it is always a blizzard?
Would you rather have the ability to become invisible but only when no one is looking, or the ability to become incredibly strong but only when you're asleep?
Would you rather have to outsmart a genius serial killer, or outrun a pack of rabid zombies?

Relatability and Everyday Dilemmas

Would you rather forget to pay your rent and get evicted, or forget to pay your credit card bill and have your credit score ruined?
Would you rather always be five minutes late for everything, or always be fifteen minutes early for everything?
Would you rather have your social media hacked and all your embarrassing posts revealed, or have your private messages leaked to your family?
Would you rather accidentally send a text meant for your partner to your boss, or accidentally send a text meant for your boss to your partner?
Would you rather have your car break down in the middle of nowhere during a storm, or have your car break down in rush hour traffic?
Would you rather have to clean a public restroom with only a toothbrush, or have to do your entire grocery shop while wearing a full-body banana costume?
Would you rather have your phone die during an important call, or have your laptop freeze during a crucial presentation?
Would you rather have your neighbor constantly borrowing your things without asking, or have your neighbor constantly complain about your music, even when it's quiet?
Would you rather forget your wallet at home when you're at the grocery store checkout, or forget your keys inside your locked car?
Would you rather have to tell your crush that you like them and be rejected publicly, or never tell them and always wonder "what if"?
Would you rather have your coworker constantly steal your ideas, or constantly take credit for your work?
Would you rather accidentally spill coffee on your boss's white shirt, or accidentally delete an important document from your boss's computer?
Would you rather have to attend every family gathering alone, or have to attend every social event with an awkward acquaintance?
Would you rather have your favorite restaurant permanently close down, or have your favorite TV show get a terrible reboot?
Would you rather have to wear socks with sandals every day, or have to wear Crocs with socks every day?
Would you rather have your children misbehave uncontrollably in public, or have them be perfectly behaved but secretly dislike you?
Would you rather have your flight delayed by 12 hours, or have your flight cancelled and have to rebook for a week later?
Would you rather accidentally "reply all" to an email with something embarrassing, or accidentally send a sensitive work email to the wrong person?
Would you rather have your alarm clock fail to go off on the most important day of the year, or have your alarm clock go off every hour on the hour, all night long?
Would you rather have to eat a whole lemon every morning, or have to do 100 jumping jacks every time you feel hungry?

Moral Would You Rather Questions are more than just a game; they’re a way to explore the complex landscape of our choices and values. By wrestling with these tricky scenarios, we can gain a better understanding of ourselves and the world around us. So next time you're presented with a tough choice, remember that even in these hypothetical situations, the way we choose can tell us a lot about who we are and what we stand for.