73 Disturbing Would You Rather Questions
73 Disturbing Would You Rather Questions

Ever played a game where you have to choose between two tough options? That's basically "Would You Rather." But what happens when those options get a little weird, a little uncomfortable, or downright spooky? That's where Disturbing Would You Rather Questions come in. These questions aren't for the faint of heart, but they can be super fun for sparking conversations and seeing how your friends' minds work.

The Twisted World of Disturbing Would You Rather

So, what exactly are Disturbing Would You Rather Questions? They're questions that present you with two challenging, bizarre, or morally gray choices. Instead of "Would you rather have a million dollars or be able to fly?", these questions push your imagination into strange and sometimes unsettling territory. They’re popular because they’re unlike anything you'd encounter in everyday life. They force you to think outside the box and consider scenarios that are totally hypothetical but incredibly vivid.

These questions are used in many ways. Sometimes they're just for a laugh, a way to entertain friends at a party or during a long car ride. Other times, they can be used to explore deeper themes. For example, they can make us think about our own values and what we consider important. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to reveal our own unique perspectives and how we process difficult choices.

Here's a little breakdown of why they're so captivating:

  • They challenge your comfort zone.
  • They often have no easy "right" answer.
  • They can lead to hilarious or thought-provoking discussions.
  • They're a great way to get to know people better.

Body Horror Edition

Would you rather:

  • Have your fingernails slowly grow into your palms every day, or have your teeth constantly feel like they're about to fall out?
  • Always have a persistent, dull ache in your stomach, or always feel like you have to sneeze but never can?
  • Be able to see through your own skin, or have your sense of taste replaced by the feeling of static electricity?
  • Have your hair made of earthworms, or have your skin feel like sandpaper all the time?
  • Constantly hear a faint buzzing sound that only you can hear, or have a phantom itch you can never scratch?
  • Have your eyes water uncontrollably for an hour each day, or have your ears constantly feel like they're clogged with water?
  • Be able to taste colors, or see sounds as fuzzy shapes?
  • Have your hands permanently smell like rotten eggs, or have your feet always feel slimy?
  • Be able to control your dreams but every dream is a nightmare, or never dream again?
  • Have your bones feel brittle and breakable, or have your muscles feel like they're constantly cramping?
  • Always feel a slight electric shock when you touch metal, or have your tongue permanently feel like it's been burned?
  • Have your nose run constantly with thick, clear mucus, or have your ears constantly drip a sticky substance?
  • Be able to communicate with insects but they are all incredibly rude, or be able to understand animals but they only complain about you?
  • Have your shadow come to life and mock you, or have your reflection try to escape the mirror?
  • Have your body temperature fluctuate wildly throughout the day, or have your skin crawl with invisible bugs?
  • Have your voice sound like a broken record, or have your laughter sound like a dying animal?
  • Be able to see your own impending death, or live forever but be constantly in pain?
  • Have your internal organs occasionally shift places, or have your limbs randomly lock up?
  • Have your sense of touch be incredibly sensitive to pain, or have your sense of smell be overwhelmingly strong?
  • Have your skin change color based on your emotions, but always to disturbing shades of grey and black?

Psychological Puzzles

Would you rather:

  • Know the exact date of your death, or know the exact date of everyone else's death except your own?
  • Be able to read minds but never be able to turn it off, or be able to forget anything instantly but also forget everything important?
  • Live a life of intense happiness but short duration, or live a long life of mild sadness?
  • Be hated by everyone you know but be universally loved by strangers, or be loved by everyone you know but despised by strangers?
  • Always know when someone is lying to you, but also always be suspected of lying yourself, or never know when someone is lying to you but be always trusted?
  • Have your greatest fear come true every single day, or have your greatest desire come true but only when you're asleep?
  • Be able to travel to the past but only as an invisible observer, or be able to travel to the future but only as a forgotten ghost?
  • Have your entire life broadcasted on TV for everyone to see, or have every embarrassing thought you've ever had published in a book?
  • Be able to control time but only in increments of one second, or be able to control space but only by teleporting one inch at a time?
  • Live in a world where everyone is exactly like you, or live in a world where everyone is the opposite of you?
  • Be able to talk to the dead but they all want something from you, or be able to talk to animals but they are all incredibly boring?
  • Have a constant feeling of dread that you can't explain, or have a constant feeling of intense joy that feels fake?
  • Be forgotten by everyone you've ever met, or be remembered for something you didn't do?
  • Live with the knowledge that you are responsible for a terrible accident, or live with the knowledge that you could have prevented a terrible accident but didn't?
  • Have your memories replaced with fictional ones, or have your personality completely rewritten?
  • Be able to communicate with aliens but they only speak in riddles, or be able to communicate with plants but they only tell you depressing facts?
  • Have every mistake you make amplified by a thousand, or have every success you achieve ignored?
  • Be able to see the future but only the negative outcomes, or be able to change the past but only for the worse?
  • Live in a simulation that feels real but you know it's fake, or live in reality but it's constantly falling apart?
  • Have your dreams become reality but they are all mundane, or have your reality become a dream but it's constantly chaotic?
  • Be able to feel the emotions of others but only the negative ones, or be able to feel your own emotions but only the dullest ones?

Existential Eek

Would you rather:

  • Live forever on a desolate planet with no other sentient life, or die tomorrow at the peak of your happiness?
  • Know that humanity is destined for extinction, or know that you are the last human alive?
  • Have your consciousness uploaded into a machine, or have your consciousness transferred into the body of an insect?
  • Be able to achieve true enlightenment but lose all sense of self, or remain flawed but retain your identity?
  • Live in a world where love is a chemical reaction that can be switched off, or live in a world where emotions are controlled by a government agency?
  • Have the ability to create life but it's always imperfect, or have the ability to destroy life but it's always painless?
  • Be the last person to remember a forgotten, terrible event, or be the first person to forget a vital, beautiful memory?
  • Have your life be completely meaningless but free of suffering, or have your life be incredibly meaningful but filled with constant pain?
  • Know the universe is indifferent to your existence, or know that you are the universe's only hope?
  • Be able to understand the true nature of reality but be unable to communicate it, or be able to spread a comforting lie to everyone?
  • Have your existence be a glitch in the matrix, or have your existence be the ultimate test?
  • Be the subject of an eternal scientific experiment, or be the sole inhabitant of a dying universe?
  • Have your soul be a shared consciousness of everyone who has ever lived, or have your soul be a unique entity that will cease to exist after death?
  • Be able to alter the laws of physics but with unpredictable consequences, or be able to understand them perfectly but never change them?
  • Live as a god in a fake world, or live as a mortal in a world of gods?
  • Know the precise moment of the universe's end, or know the precise moment of your own rebirth?
  • Be able to experience all of human history simultaneously, or be able to experience all of future human history simultaneously?
  • Have your existence be a paradox, or have your existence be an illusion?
  • Be the first to discover intelligent alien life and they are hostile, or be the last to discover intelligent alien life and they are extinct?
  • Know that you are dreaming and unable to wake up, or know that you are awake and everything is a dream?

Morally Murky Waters

Would you rather:

  • Save one innocent person by sacrificing ten guilty people, or let ten guilty people go free to save one innocent person?
  • Betray your best friend for immense personal gain, or remain loyal and struggle your whole life?
  • Have the power to end all suffering in the world but have to commit one heinous act to do it, or let suffering continue?
  • Steal from the rich to give to the poor and be caught, or let the rich hoard all their wealth and prosper?
  • Be forced to lie to your loved ones every day for the rest of your life, or be forced to tell them the harsh truth every day?
  • Have the ability to control people's actions but never your own, or have the ability to control your own actions but never anyone else's?
  • Save your family by dooming an entire stranger's family, or sacrifice your family to save a stranger's family?
  • Be able to erase the memory of a terrible crime from everyone's mind, or bring the perpetrator to justice and cause immense pain?
  • Have the power to make everyone happy but they lose all individuality, or let people suffer but retain their uniqueness?
  • Be a benevolent dictator who rules with an iron fist but provides for everyone, or be a weak leader in a chaotic democracy?
  • Be able to see into the future and prevent tragedies, but you have to make a difficult ethical compromise each time, or let tragedies happen naturally?
  • Have your children become incredibly successful but morally corrupt, or have your children be incredibly virtuous but live in poverty?
  • Be able to grant wishes to everyone but each wish has a terrible unintended consequence, or grant no wishes at all?
  • Be a villain who is loved and admired by the masses, or a hero who is reviled and hated?
  • Have the ability to know the true intentions of everyone you meet but be unable to act on it, or have the ability to act on your intentions but never know the truth?
  • Be able to erase all war from the world but it means the end of all art and culture, or let war continue with the preservation of creativity?
  • Be able to take away someone's pain but absorb it yourself forever, or let them continue to suffer?
  • Be the one to start a war that unites humanity against a common enemy, or live in a divided world?
  • Have the power to choose who lives and who dies, but you can never experience love again, or live a normal life filled with love?
  • Be able to make everyone believe a lie that brings peace, or tell the truth and cause chaos?

Absurd Adventures

Would you rather:

  • Ride a giant, sentient banana through space, or swim across an ocean of fizzy soda on a waffle boat?
  • Have a pet dragon that breathes bubblegum-scented smoke, or have a pet unicorn that sneezes glitter?
  • Be able to talk to vegetables but they only complain about the soil, or be able to control clouds but they only make tiny, useless rain showers?
  • Wear a suit made entirely of spaghetti, or wear shoes made of living jelly?
  • Have your house be a giant teapot, or have your car be a flying donut?
  • Be able to breathe underwater but only when you're singing opera, or be able to fly but only when you're juggling?
  • Have a nose that honks like a clown car every time you laugh, or have ears that play circus music when you're excited?
  • Be able to communicate with inanimate objects but they all have terrible fashion sense, or be able to communicate with furniture but they only give terrible advice?
  • Have your shadow be a mischievous monkey, or have your reflection be a disco ball?
  • Be able to teleport but only to places you've never been, or be able to fly but only backwards?
  • Have a personal cloud that follows you everywhere and rains candy, or have a personal rainbow that follows you and plays annoying jingles?
  • Be able to control gravity but only for things that are blue, or be able to control temperature but only for things that are round?
  • Have your hands turn into tiny accordions whenever you're nervous, or have your feet turn into bouncy springs when you're happy?
  • Live in a world where everyone communicates by interpretive dance, or live in a world where everyone speaks in riddles?
  • Have a magical toilet that dispenses endless supplies of cheese, or a magical refrigerator that dispenses endless supplies of mismatched socks?
  • Be able to shrink yourself to the size of an ant but only when you're sleeping, or be able to grow to the size of a skyscraper but only when you're singing?
  • Have a pet sentient sock puppet that gives you life advice, or have a pet sentient rubber chicken that tells you terrible jokes?
  • Be able to taste music but it all tastes like broccoli, or be able to hear colors but they all sound like static?
  • Have your dreams be narrated by a booming game show host, or have your waking life be soundtracked by a kazoo orchestra?
  • Wear a hat that makes you invisible but it smells like feet, or wear a cape that makes you super strong but it's made of itchy wool?

Disturbing Would You Rather Questions are definitely not for everyone, but they're a fantastic way to get people thinking, laughing, and sometimes even a little freaked out. They prove that even the most bizarre scenarios can spark interesting conversations and reveal surprising things about ourselves and our friends. So, the next time you're looking for a way to liven things up, break out some of these thought-provoking, and a little bit scary, questions!

Related Articles: