73 Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions
73 Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions

The holiday season is a time for joy, family, and of course, a little bit of fun! And what better way to inject some festive cheer into your gatherings than with a round of Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions? These questions are perfect for sparking conversations, revealing surprising preferences, and getting everyone laughing. So grab some hot cocoa and get ready to dive into some delightfully tricky holiday dilemmas!

What Are Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions?

Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions are simply fun scenarios that force you to pick between two equally interesting (or sometimes hilariously unappealing) Christmas-related options. They're like little brain teasers that make you think about what you truly value during the holiday season. They work by presenting a dilemma, and because both choices are usually kind of good or kind of bad, it makes the decision-making process really engaging. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to break the ice, foster connection, and create memorable moments. They're not about finding the "right" answer, but about exploring the possibilities and seeing how others think.

People love them for a few key reasons:

  • They're low-stakes fun: You don't have to worry about making a real-life decision, just a fun hypothetical one.
  • They reveal personality: Your choices can tell your friends and family a lot about what you find important or funny.
  • They're easy to play: All you need are the questions and people willing to answer them.

You can use Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions in so many ways!

  1. Around the Christmas tree during gift exchange.
  2. During a holiday dinner to keep the conversation lively.
  3. On long car rides to visit family.
  4. As a fun icebreaker at a Christmas party.
  5. Even just texting them to friends to spread some holiday spirit.

Santa's Dilemmas

  • Would you rather have to personally deliver all the presents by reindeer or by a magical sleigh that can only go 10 mph?
  • Would you rather be Santa Claus and have to eat all the cookies left out for you, or be an elf and have to listen to carols on repeat for a month straight?
  • Would you rather only be able to communicate by singing Christmas carols, or only be able to move by doing a clumsy ice skate walk?
  • Would you rather have a beard made of tinsel that sheds everywhere, or have to wear elf shoes that are three sizes too big all the time?
  • Would you rather have to answer every question with a "Ho ho ho," or only be able to say "Merry Christmas"?
  • Would you rather have your sleigh pulled by 10 very grumpy reindeer or 10 very hyperactive elves?
  • Would you rather be forced to wear a Santa suit year-round, or wear a full elf costume every day in December?
  • Would you rather have to laugh like Santa constantly, or only be able to walk backwards?
  • Would you rather have a sack of presents that weighs 1000 pounds, or a sack of presents that constantly plays jingle bells?
  • Would you rather have to eat only gingerbread cookies and milk for every meal, or only eat fruitcake?
  • Would you rather your workshop be filled with incredibly loud jackhammers, or incredibly quiet whispers that drive you crazy?
  • Would you rather have to mend every toy by hand with thread, or have to paint every toy with glitter that never washes off?
  • Would you rather have a single, gigantic candy cane to eat, or an endless supply of tiny candy canes?
  • Would you rather have to travel to every house in an ice storm, or in a heatwave?
  • Would you rather your reindeer have to wear tiny Christmas sweaters, or your elves have to wear full snow gear indoors?
  • Would you rather have to sing a different Christmas carol for every delivery, or have to tell a different Christmas joke?
  • Would you rather your belly jiggle like jelly, or your nose glow like a Rudolph?
  • Would you rather have to give away all your cookies to strangers, or have to eat all the burnt cookies yourself?
  • Would you rather have to constantly smell like peppermint, or constantly smell like pine needles?
  • Would you rather have to wear mistletoe on your hat at all times, or have jingle bells on your shoes that never stop ringing?

Decorating Disasters

  • Would you rather have a Christmas tree that sheds needles non-stop, or a Christmas tree that is always slightly on fire?
  • Would you rather only be able to decorate with tinsel that tangles into impossible knots, or only with lights that flicker and go out every five minutes?
  • Would you rather have your house covered in fake snow that never melts and sticks to everything, or real snow that causes constant avalanches?
  • Would you rather have a giant inflatable snowman that deflates and re-inflates randomly, or a nativity scene where the animals come to life at night?
  • Would you rather your Christmas lights be a single, blindingly bright color, or a chaotic rainbow that changes speed unpredictably?
  • Would you rather have to wear a gingerbread man costume while decorating, or have to wear a reindeer antler headband that keeps falling off?
  • Would you rather have to hang ornaments made of raw onions, or ornaments made of extremely sticky marshmallows?
  • Would you rather your stockings be so small they only fit a single candy, or so large they drag on the floor?
  • Would you rather have to put up a 100-foot-tall Christmas tree, or have to wrap every single present in a 100-foot roll of paper?
  • Would you rather have your garland be made of live snakes, or your mistletoe be made of poison ivy?
  • Would you rather have to sing carols loudly while decorating, or have to do a dance routine with every ornament hung?
  • Would you rather have your tree topper be a disco ball, or a giant, talking rubber chicken?
  • Would you rather have to decorate your entire house with only red and white stripes, or only green and blue polka dots?
  • Would you rather have to use only glitter glue for all your decorations, or only use sticky tape that never comes off?
  • Would you rather have your tree lights constantly beep, or constantly hum loudly?
  • Would you rather have to decorate in a blizzard, or in a monsoon?
  • Would you rather your ornaments all be made of very sharp glass, or very heavy rocks?
  • Would you rather have to wear a hat that shoots confetti every time you look up, or shoes that squeak like a clown?
  • Would you rather have to build a gingerbread house that is twice as tall as you, or a gingerbread village with at least 50 tiny houses?
  • Would you rather have to hang your decorations by climbing a very wobbly ladder, or by being swung on a rope?

Gift Giving Gaffes

  • Would you rather always receive socks as presents, or always give socks as presents?
  • Would you rather have to wrap all your gifts in newspaper, or in fabric scraps that fray?
  • Would you rather receive a lump of coal every year, or receive a gift that is always the wrong size?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that you made yourself and it turns out terrible, or give a gift that you bought and it's incredibly expensive?
  • Would you rather have your presents always be slightly damaged, or always be slightly late?
  • Would you rather have to give gifts only to people you dislike, or receive gifts only from people you dislike?
  • Would you rather your gift wrapping be so bad it's illegible, or so elaborate it takes an hour to open?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that's secretly a prank, or receive a gift that's secretly a prank?
  • Would you rather always receive a fruitcake, or always give a fruitcake?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that's impossible to get rid of, or receive a gift that's impossible to get rid of?
  • Would you rather have your presents always smell like old cheese, or always sound like a loud fart?
  • Would you rather have to wrap gifts using only one hand, or with your eyes closed?
  • Would you rather always receive a gag gift that's truly useless, or receive a gift that's deeply embarrassing?
  • Would you rather have to deliver gifts via a broken drone, or a unicycle?
  • Would you rather have your gift tags be unreadable riddles, or have to guess who each gift is from?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that's a live animal, or a gift that's a very large rock?
  • Would you rather have your presents always be slightly damp, or always be slightly sticky?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that's extremely loud, or extremely quiet and fragile?
  • Would you rather have your gift bows always come undone, or your gift ribbon always get tangled?
  • Would you rather have to give a gift that’s a famous historical artifact, or a gift that’s a rare, exotic animal?

Festive Food Fails

  • Would you rather eat only gingerbread cookies for a week, or only candy canes for a week?
  • Would you rather have your Christmas dinner be entirely burnt, or entirely raw?
  • Would you rather have to eat all your vegetables with whipped cream, or all your desserts with gravy?
  • Would you rather have your hot chocolate be incredibly spicy, or incredibly sour?
  • Would you rather have to eat only fruitcake for every meal, or only eggnog for every meal?
  • Would you rather have your Christmas pudding be made of rocks, or your Christmas crackers be filled with spiders?
  • Would you rather have to drink unsweetened cranberry juice all Christmas day, or unsweetened prune juice?
  • Would you rather your gingerbread men be missing limbs, or have extra eyes?
  • Would you rather have to make a turkey out of Jell-O, or a ham out of marshmallows?
  • Would you rather have your candy canes be made of chalk, or your chocolates be made of soap?
  • Would you rather have to eat your Christmas dinner with only a spoon, or only chopsticks?
  • Would you rather have your Christmas cookies taste like dirt, or your Christmas cake taste like cardboard?
  • Would you rather have to drink pickle juice instead of mulled wine, or vinegar instead of cider?
  • Would you rather have to make a Yule log out of actual logs, or a trifle out of dirt?
  • Would you rather have your candy corn be all bitter, or all mushy?
  • Would you rather have to eat a whole onion like an apple, or a whole lemon like a berry?
  • Would you rather have your stuffing be made of old shoes, or your gravy be made of mud?
  • Would you rather have to eat your Christmas dinner backwards, or have to sing while you eat?
  • Would you rather have your mistletoe berries be poisonous, or your holly berries be made of glass?
  • Would you rather have to eat a Brussels sprout that’s alive, or a raisin that’s radioactive?

Holiday Entertainment Horrors

  • Would you rather have to watch "A Christmas Story" on repeat for 24 hours straight, or listen to "The 12 Days of Christmas" sung by a broken record for 24 hours straight?
  • Would you rather have to attend a Christmas play where all the actors forget their lines, or a Christmas concert where all the instruments are out of tune?
  • Would you rather have to sing carols in public every day for a month, or dance in a Santa suit every day for a month?
  • Would you rather have to go ice skating with a clumsy penguin, or sledding with a runaway snowball?
  • Would you rather have to read "Twas the Night Before Christmas" with a terrible lisp, or with a robotic voice?
  • Would you rather have to watch every single Hallmark Christmas movie ever made, or every single B-grade Santa movie ever made?
  • Would you rather have to wear elf shoes that make you trip every time you walk, or reindeer antlers that constantly get caught on things?
  • Would you rather have to participate in a snowball fight where the snowballs are made of rocks, or a gift-opening contest where the gifts are all empty boxes?
  • Would you rather have to listen to Christmas music played on a kazoo, or Christmas music sung by a screeching cat?
  • Would you rather have to write a Christmas card to every single person you’ve ever met, or receive a Christmas card from every single person you’ve ever met?
  • Would you rather have to help Santa deliver presents, but you have to wear a giant bell that can't be silenced, or help Mrs. Claus bake cookies, but the flour is made of glitter?
  • Would you rather have to go caroling with a group of off-key singers, or a group of mime artists?
  • Would you rather have to spend Christmas day in a haunted gingerbread house, or a haunted ice palace?
  • Would you rather have to play a Christmas board game where all the rules change randomly, or a Christmas card game where you can only use one hand?
  • Would you rather have to build a snowman that constantly melts and has to be rebuilt, or a gingerbread house that constantly gets eaten by mice?
  • Would you rather have to watch a Christmas movie where the sound is completely off, or where the picture is completely upside down?
  • Would you rather have to wear elf shoes that are impossibly loud, or elf ears that are impossibly itchy?
  • Would you rather have to sing a Christmas carol in a language you don't understand, or act out a Christmas scene without any props?
  • Would you rather have to attend a Christmas party where everyone speaks in riddles, or a Christmas party where everyone communicates through interpretive dance?
  • Would you rather have to listen to Christmas songs played backward, or Christmas movies shown in reverse?

Winter Wonderland Woes

  • Would you rather be trapped in a blizzard with no heat, or trapped in a blizzard with a faulty heater that makes things incredibly hot?
  • Would you rather have to build a snow fort that immediately collapses, or an ice sculpture that melts within minutes?
  • Would you rather have to wear snow boots that are way too small, or snow gloves that are way too big?
  • Would you rather have to walk through knee-deep slush for your entire Christmas day, or have to walk through ankle-deep ice?
  • Would you rather have your Christmas tree be made of ice that keeps dripping, or a Christmas tree made of snow that keeps melting?
  • Would you rather have to slide down a very steep, icy hill on a garbage can lid, or a very bumpy hill on a sled with no steering?
  • Would you rather have to go to the North Pole and only wear shorts, or wear a thick winter coat in the desert?
  • Would you rather have to drink ice water that's not cold enough, or hot chocolate that's not hot enough?
  • Would you rather have to play in the snow with a broken shovel, or build a snowman with no tools at all?
  • Would you rather have to wear a scarf that's too short to cover your neck, or a hat that's too small for your head?
  • Would you rather have to get stuck in a snowdrift for an hour, or have to cross a frozen lake that’s slightly cracked?
  • Would you rather have to walk barefoot in the snow, or wear shoes filled with ice?
  • Would you rather have your snowball fight with real snow that's too wet to pack, or with pretend snow that's too hard to throw?
  • Would you rather have to build a snow fort with only your hands, or an ice sculpture with only your teeth?
  • Would you rather have to wear mittens that are full of holes, or a scarf that's constantly unraveling?
  • Would you rather have to go sledding on a hill made of mud, or a hill made of very sharp rocks?
  • Would you rather have to wear a hat that’s constantly falling off, or a scarf that’s constantly getting tangled?
  • Would you rather have to sleep in a tent made of ice, or a tent made of snow that’s leaking?
  • Would you rather have to drink from a frozen water bottle, or eat from a frozen plate?
  • Would you rather have to walk around with icicles hanging from your nose, or frostbite on your fingers?

So there you have it! A whole list of Christmas Themed Would You Rather Questions to keep you entertained all holiday season long. Whether you're trying to liven up a party, get to know your family better, or just have a good laugh, these questions are sure to be a hit. So go forth, pick your dilemmas, and have a wonderfully whimsical Christmas!

Related Articles: